Made for television movie

I am looking for the title of a movie that is suppose to be a true story. A community in Pennsylvania (in the 20’s or 30’s I think) are losing a lot of livestock and children during birthing’s. They suspect that a newly arrived stranger may be responsible for these deaths. The communities preacher ends up in a fight with this man and kills him and leaves him to burn in a house that is on fire. Then they show the preacher being hauled off my the cops. The preacher was also a powwower, which is kind of like a Pennsylvania Deutcsh medicene man.